Of course, you know I don’t have a cat. Terribly allergic. I am referring to Christopher Smart’s cat, and the lovely poem he wrote in tribute.
In class the other day, when I was speaking to my students about the writing process, and I told them that although writing is fundamentally a solitary activity, it is also a social activity — that we write in order to share a piece of our inner experience with others. I think James Baldwin said something like, “You think your pain and suffering is unique in the history of the world, but then you read.”
And when I was telling them this, my eyes welled up, and then my voice cracked, which immediately got everyone’s undivided attention.
Later, a very sweet and concerned student wrote me an email that essentially said, “I read the poem, and I can’t figure out why it made you cry. Please explain to me what you are seeing.”
So I wrote back.
I found this poem in the most accidental, serendipitous way — in fact, I could not even tell you how I discovered it. It was not in a class or even in a book, or anything. It was just there, somehow in the world, waiting for me to find it. When stuff like that happens, I perk up. My attention is quickened. I find Smart’s poem charming, and I will be able to read it without growing bored of it for the span of my life; I love the idea that an animal — in expressing its true nature — is expressing God’s will. (Does that mean that when I express my true nature, that I am expressing God’ s will? If so, what is my true nature? And that, my dear, is a question that we can ponder every day: Am I expressing my true nature today? Or am I expressing someone else’s idea for me?) But what sometimes chokes me up is NOT the poem itself…it’s the knowledge that words live on longer than mortal human being, and that words retain the power to touch us and move us far longer than an ordinary human life span. Of course, we know this any time we pick up the words of any dead author…(I’ve been thinking of this often lately as I read David Foster Wallace, a brilliant writer and compassionate human being who committed suicide in 2008.) Black lines on paper EVOKE MEANING that transcend space and time. This never fails to amaze me. And then I think of Christopher Smart in the asylum — what must an asylum been like in 16th century England? I ask myself, “Did he imagine that his words would reach a 20th century woman in Southern California?” and of course, the answer is no. What a ridiculous idea that would have been for him. I wonder if he was cold, or if he was hungry, or if he was lonely. I know he was alone, writing poetry, with nobody for company but his cat Jeofrey, a “mixture of gravity and waggery… For God has blessed him in the variety of his movements. For, tho he cannot fly, he is an excellent clamberer. For his motions upon the face of the earth are more than any other quadrupede. For he can tread to all the measures upon the musick For he can swim for life. For he can creep.” And it GRABS ME RIGHT IN THE HEART.
I found this poem in the most accidental, serendipitous way — in fact, I could not even tell you how I discovered it. It was not in a class or even in a book, or anything. It was just there, somehow in the world, waiting for me to find it. When stuff like that happens, I perk up. My attention is quickened.
I find Smart’s poem charming, and I will be able to read it without growing bored of it for the span of my life; I love the idea that an animal — in expressing its true nature — is expressing God’s will. (Does that mean that when I express my true nature, that I am expressing God’ s will? If so, what is my true nature? And that, my dear, is a question that we can ponder every day: Am I expressing my true nature today? Or am I expressing someone else’s idea for me?)
But what sometimes chokes me up is NOT the poem itself…it’s the knowledge that words live on longer than mortal human being, and that words retain the power to touch us and move us far longer than an ordinary human life span. Of course, we know this any time we pick up the words of any dead author…(I’ve been thinking of this often lately as I read David Foster Wallace, a brilliant writer and compassionate human being who committed suicide in 2008.) Black lines on paper EVOKE MEANING that transcend space and time. This never fails to amaze me.
And then I think of Christopher Smart in the asylum — what must an asylum been like in 16th century England? I ask myself, “Did he imagine that his words would reach a 20th century woman in Southern California?” and of course, the answer is no. What a ridiculous idea that would have been for him.
I wonder if he was cold, or if he was hungry, or if he was lonely. I know he was alone, writing poetry, with nobody for company but his cat Jeofrey,
a “mixture of gravity and waggery… For God has blessed him in the variety of his movements. For, tho he cannot fly, he is an excellent clamberer. For his motions upon the face of the earth are more than any other quadrupede. For he can tread to all the measures upon the musick For he can swim for life. For he can creep.”
And it GRABS ME RIGHT IN THE HEART.
You are the bread and the knife, The crystal goblet and the wine… -Jacques Crickillon
You are the bread and the knife, the crystal goblet and the wine. You are the dew on the morning grass and the burning wheel of the sun. You are the white apron of the baker, and the marsh birds suddenly in flight.
However, you are not the wind in the orchard, the plums on the counter, or the house of cards. And you are certainly not the pine-scented air. There is just no way that you are the pine-scented air.
It is possible that you are the fish under the bridge, maybe even the pigeon on the general’s head, but you are not even close to being the field of cornflowers at dusk.
And a quick look in the mirror will show that you are neither the boots in the corner nor the boat asleep in its boathouse.
It might interest you to know, speaking of the plentiful imagery of the world, that I am the sound of rain on the roof.
I also happen to be the shooting star, the evening paper blowing down an alley and the basket of chestnuts on the kitchen table.
I am also the moon in the trees and the blind woman’s tea cup. But don’t worry, I’m not the bread and the knife. You are still the bread and the knife. You will always be the bread and the knife, not to mention the crystal goblet and–somehow–the wine.
Green dresser, circa 1944
My daughter Maddy moved out today. She is 23 now, and moving into her first one-bedroom apartment is an important milestone. And no roommate. This is not college, where she is subsidized by savings and scholarships and loans – she went out and found this place, put a deposit down, and now must pay for it, month in and month out. She has done the math a hundred different ways, and is sure she will be able to handle everything comfortably. She has a good job in Pomona that looks like it will last for a good while. Although…it seem as if this company may be acquired soon — the principal owner is eighty years old — and there is certain to be a shake up. If she continues to demonstrate her worth, she may be spared and integrated into the new organization. All this is new to her, but this is what I worry about.
But why worry? That girl has always landed on her feet. She’s smart, and resourceful. And I don’t know anything about the company she works for. I’m making it all up in my head.
I went to go see the apartment yesterday; it’s cute. It’s on a quiet street, tucked in an older Fullerton neighborhood, within walking distance from the “action” of downtown — corners of Harbor and Commonwealth. It’s exactly the kind of place a 23-year old girl should live in: tiny, clean, with families all around, and a big avocado tree outside. Today, she packed her room, loaded up her car and drove away, with very little fanfare. She said, “I’ll see you tomorrow.” My eyebrows shot up. “Are you sleeping there tonight?,” I wanted to know. She shrugged. Maddy has no bed, no fridge, no gas on for the stove, no coffeepot, no couch, no table, no chair. But she’s all dressed up, and anxious to go find her friends, haul her stuff upstairs, and then drink too much.
I face the emptiness of my house with a mixture of elation and grief. I am going to miss her, but I don’t think mothers should have a front row seat to their daughters’ 20s. It’s not a pretty decade. There are bad decisions, tragic love affairs and ill-fated liaisons; there’s vomit in the driveway and cigarette butts spilling over their ashtrays. I moved far, far away so my mother’s worries were vague and diaphanous; she couldn’t really put her finger on what troubled her, whereas I see it all, up close. I’d prefer to see less. I am banking on Maddy emerging from this decade alive, wiser, and appreciative of what it takes to keep a household together, day after day, month after month, for years following years. It’s no mean feat.
I have little money to help her, so we are relying on her dad, who has been generous and accommodating. Today, though — he’s depressed, and not up for shopping with me. He’s been in a whirlwind of activity all week with his sister and her family down for Easter vacation; he can’t do too much before he falls into his morass of dark emotion.
I called a green dresser back into service — it used to belong to my sister, but it’s been the garage now for at least 25 years — so when I pulled it away from the wall in the garage, I found black widow spiders, rat poop and mold. I ran inside to get a mask to go over my nose and mouth, and a scarf to cover my hair, and then I started to methodically clean this piece of furniture that we surely had on Winchester Street. This dresser dates back to at least the 1960s; Vicki thinks that it might be from the 1940s. I remember my mother painting it that crazy green color, but which house were we in then? Spain? Morocco? Petunia Court in San Diego? It has big round white ceramic drawer pulls – very 1970s in appearance. I dusted it off, killed the spider nests, took a wire brush to every inside surface, vacuumed it, sprayed it with Lysol, wiped it down with Clorox, and left it disassembled to air out. It was a process, and during my work, I thought of my mother, and moving away from her house many different times.
When I was 23, I was already in the north, flailing around. My mother was in this house, the one that I live in today. I had abandoned my Southern California life, and that included her. I didn’t think of it that way at the time, of course, but I am a mother now, and I know now how she experienced my departure.
It’s not that I want Maddy to stay. In many ways, I am relieved to have my house to myself once again; I suffered one hundred little indignities as Maddy’s roommate. But my heart is breaking anyway. My child is grown, and her life belongs to her; I am no longer needed. Well, I haven’t been needed as a “mom” for a long time, and I suppose she needs to remind me of that simple truth as a declaration of independence. Providing food, shelter, safety and entertainment is a paltry thing compared with being somebody’s capital-M Mom. There was a time when she adored me, but now, as she completes her separation, she must articulate all of the ways she does not need me, the ways that she exceeds me, the things that she knows better, the ways that I oppress her with worry or care. She has to push me to the side, as I pushed my own mother aside. As I scrub out the green dresser that my mother painted, I regret my part in this stupid cycle.
It’s off to Target for a dish drainer and a broom, a pot holder and a dish towel. She needs everything. I try not to think about the San Luis Obispo yard sale I sat at 10 months ago, when everything I had ever given her was up for sale for a song. She sold it all and hit the road with Hannah for their WWOOF adventure. Less than a year down the road, she’s a full time quality control chemist, starting a new life, and she needs a broom. She will be fine. I will be fine. Life is not through with us yet.
A short speech I wrote and presented at today’s faculty meeting
I am addressing you this morning on behalf of our students who are members of the Gay-Straight Alliance, and also for those kids who hang on the periphery of the club.
First of all, a little history: the Gay-Straight Alliance started up here at Mayfair just last year, in the spring — although GSAs have existed in high schools around the country since the ‘90s. There’s an enormous national network of GSAs. Our little baby GSA will be participating in our 3rd club’s day this week, passing out ribbons and raising awareness. We’re a club that is still finding its identity and its purpose — well, obviously, a Gay-Straight Alliance has a ready-made identity and a purpose on a philosophical or symbolic level, but on a practical level, the kids have been trying to figure out what they want to do, and how they can contribute productively to life at our school.
But then, unfortunately, the recent tragic suicide of Rutgers freshman Tyler Clementi brought national attention to issue of bullying. It also brought attention to three other teen suicides that had not really made national news: Seth Walsh, 13, in California; Asher Brown, 13, in Texas; and Billy Lucas, 15, in Indiana. These teens, bullied by their peers for being different, decided that the best thing to do was to end their lives.
I have always been impressed by Mayfair’s diversity, and by how well we get along. We don’t, as a rule, experience many of the social tensions that we read about on other campuses. But, all the same, the students of the GSA have asked me to deliver this message.
As the adults on campus, please hold the line — in your classrooms and anytime within your earshot — on the phrase, “That’s so gay,” or any of the gay, faggoty, or queer quips that kids come up with. These phrases may seem meaningless to some of us, analogous to saying that something is dumb or juvenile. In fact, the phrase “that’s so gay” travels up with kids from the elementary schools, so in that sense, it is juvenile; it is also a phrase that many kids use, and are able to use apparently without being consistently challenged by adults.
But that phrase — no matter how benign it may seem to you — does two things for sure: first, there are kids who hear this as deeply offensive – comparable to hearing the Lord’s name in vain, or the f-word, or the n-word, or any racist or hate speech. But secondly, and more importantly, I think, is that it contributes to an atmosphere that accepts such speech and therefore accepts such thinking.
There is a young man on our campus who comes to the GSA meetings, and I don’t know his name. (I tend to sit to the side, and let the kids run their meeting.) And although he did not share this story with me himself, his friends have told me that because of his appearance and his demeanor, he is regularly a target of hostile speech that is delivered in the friendliest of tones. Kids walk past him and say, “Hey, there’s that faggot,” or “Hey! Aren’t you a faggot?” Fortunately, this student has a strong network of support through his family and his friends, so he has developed the confidence and the necessary inner resources to cope with these exchanges, but why on earth should he have to? And what about the kids who don’t have supportive families, or have only a few friends? Or no friends they can really count on?
Now, kids are crafty, and mostly manage to hold back their worst behavior when adults are present. I am sure that if any of us had heard anyone address this young man as a faggot, we would have stepped in and said something. But we are not going to always witness the things that happen on this campus. There’s the world we know about, and then, there is another world entirely.
I’d like to suggest that a campus that tolerates “that’s so gay,” is to some degree complicit when kids use more aggressive hate speech, like “hey, are you a faggot?”
So just like the frayed jeans rule, let’s not make it up to the kids to decide what degree of hate speech is OK. Say no to all of it. In the classroom, in the walkways, in the gym —hold the line on any form of hate speech, including the phrase, “that’s so gay.”
Thank you.
McCartney (1970) featured cherries and a bowl of juice, not a cake.
I guess I was thinking of Let it Bleed by The Rolling Stones (1969)…
I am remembering music and art from 40 years ago. How can that be??
Scroll down to read this story from the bottom up.
Went to Twitter just now, to report hitting my daily word count, and three quotes from Nicole Krauss were just sitting there, right on top of the feed:
“Writing is never really fun. It is many things, but it is not that.”
“I’ve gotten used to the terror [of failure], but the terror never really goes away.”
“Writing for me is very hard work. It is very sweaty labor. I am always aware of blowing breath into my characters.”
I *heart* Nicole Krauss, and her amazing partner, Jonathan Safran Foer. I just finished Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close this week. I so admire his ability to really take his story to the bone of human sorrow and suffering — and then he manages to deliver us to another shore, to rest, to soak in the warmth of the sun, to fully absorb the effect of our arduous journey. I may not understand the reasons we have to travel this way, but I know that I have done it, and will do it again.
500 words a crack. During the school year I can’t commit to that regular, daily habit that is essential for writers, but I can say that when I sit down to write, I will hit my word count. And I think, as usual, I am going to have to freewrite and bitch for a while before I know what is to emerge from this.
I have been a writer my whole life, but not a writer who has been driven to complete anything that has not been commissioned by someone else. I always read that people write because “they must.” That has not been my experience. I have demons, like most people, but those demons don’t compel me to write. Who knows, though? Maybe my mental health will improve if I give voice to the doubters banging around in my psyche.
With Patricia’s help, I built a big, wobbly table in Foresthill and put my typewriter on it. I wrote bad poetry all through my youth, and read it at open readings. It was enough to shock back then, to say the phrase “bury my face in balls” and listen for the crowd reaction, to find myself suddenly surrounded by young male poets after the reading, and to believe that they were there because they appreciated my way with language, not because they could imagine their balls on my face. Where have I ended up? Satisfied by writing good and interesting papers in school, writing for work and seeing my heavily edited words printed on glossy sales and company promotional materials, and then finally, teaching young people to write, and reading thousands upon thousands of dull, predictable essays, waiting for the occasional excellent one to surface from the pile. And they do. I’ve coached very good writers, and I’ve helped mediocre writers get better, and enabled bad writers to write one coherent, clear essay to carry with them into college so they can say to themselves, “See? It is possible. I am able to write – it may not be beautiful or incredibly insightful, but it is clear and understandable.”
But what about me? What about the things I must say? What about my topics? What are my concerns as a writer and as a person? Much of what I have to say concerns my family and my life, but I do want to leave that space and move into a fictional, imaginative space, where I am free to tell the truth without naming names. I think this may be the way to go. Memoir is so confessional, denier cri—of the moment— but I do believe that moment has passed. But again, Anne Lamott would say I am focused on the wrong end of the process, and I believe that is true. I cannot think about markets and publishers; I must think only of what will emerge.
I was listening to Nicole Krauss when she was interviewed on NPR right as Great House was coming out. The interviewer asked, “Where do you get your ideas for your stories?” and she said something that I found enormously helpful and encouraging— she said, “I have no idea.” She went on to explain that she sat down to write, never knowing what the story was, who the characters were, what the problem was; she knew nothing. The interviewer then asked, “Isn’t that dangerous? What if all of your work comes to naught?” (Or, something like that. I’m not sure she used the word “naught.”) And Nicole Krauss said, firmly establishing herself as another writing hero, model, and guide, “I feel you must work right on the edge of failure. That’s where the energy is.” Or something like that. Brilliant.
But it’s HARD to do that. I want my writing to matter. But I am willing, finally and at last, to sit at this computer and write, every day…and by that I mean, every day that it is humanly possible, so if I miss a day, I am not going to give up on myself in despair. And if nothing comes of it, so be it. It is worthwhile work, even if no one else ever reads it. And, I am going to post every week to the alexfaye.com blog. In fact, I think I may put this out there, right now. No one reads me, except perhaps my sister. So I will write directly to her, with her face in my mind, and tell her everything that I am thinking.
Writing, like Weight Watchers, is just something that I do. It’s a daily practice. It is imperfect, and I will make mistakes. But the trick is to return to it, every day. It’s Zen Buddhism. It’s yoga. It’s a way through. Today’s word count: 789.
Maddy and Hannah are taking some time off from the farm they were working on in Carnation, and they are traveling around the Seattle area, checking things out. A hero of theirs — Dan Savage — writes and works in Seattle; they are visiting museums, eating, taking in the city. And my mother’s family lives in the area — Anacortes — so Maddy made contact the other day by telephone, and made arrangements to go up for a visit on Sunday. The subject of sleeping accommodations on Sunday night naturally came up when Maddy and I were discussing the upcoming visit. Where would the girls sleep?
Well, I have an aunt and an uncle in Anacortes, so I assumed it would be no trouble for one of them to put up two girls for the night. But as I write this, this is still unresolved — after emails and multiple phone calls, it turns out that I may be wrong. My mother’s people are stand-offish, and not particularly anxious to extend overnight hospitality. My aunt and her kids have not returned my phone calls about the matter, and my uncle — after his wife already told me that it would be alright, since they have a bedroom in their basement — just wrote to say, “they weren’t expecting an overnight visit, and they will help make arrangements that will fit our needs.” What in the hell does THAT mean?
And suddenly, this whole part of my family comes into sharp focus.
I live alone, and like it that way. My sister lives in the neighboring state. We see each other occasionally, and speak in big flurries of communication with long periods of rest in between. Despite this distance, there is an implicit understanding that no matter what, we will be present for one other, and we would certainly take each other in.
Having said that, I know my own reticence about taking in distant relations, or friends of friends. I would hesitate if asked.
But now I know what that reticence looks like from the other side, because even though I KNOW that this is not personal, I can’t help but take it personally. I am flabbergasted that my own mother’s people would hesitate or deny my daughter shelter for one goddamned night.
When I am in my 70s and 80s, I pray that I remember this moment, because I know the older I get, the more set in my ways that I am. Good Lord, may I never become this inflexible and closed up. May I never deny anyone who asks — and especially my own flesh and blood — a bed for the night.
Now I see why the family in Washington never sees or speaks to one another. My aunt and uncle have not spoken to one another in several years. One cousin doesn’t speak to her father or any of her siblings. Another cousin hid from my sister when she stopped in to his store to visit; his employees told her that he was not there. No wonder my mother put that small town and its people far behind her.
But even our own mother…our mom turned Vicki and her husband away once. Vicki reminded me today that mama apologized for that incident as she lived out her last days from her hospital bed. But I can’t help but believe that was my father’s strong influence over my mother — I find it impossible to think that my mother would, on her own, turn aside her daughter. And when Vicki went up to see the family in Anacortes, she had to ask for a glass of water. The convivial sitting around a table with a bottle of wine or a pot of coffee just don’t happen easily. Those familial, communal moments do not just unfold naturally in Anacortes any more.
Yet Vicki assures me, (and I somehow know this is true) — that if our grandmother Helen were alive — this would never happen. She was a warm and welcoming woman. She may not have had anything, but she would never have turned anyone away. My strongest grandma memory is being in her big soft bed with her, awake past bedtime, partners in crime, eating snacks and peeping out the window at the kids: my mother, her brothers and sisters, and all the spouses. My mom and the aunts and uncles seemed so grown up, connected, and fun that night. (Drunk — in the funny, happy way.) The doors were off when Helen was alive. Everyone was everywhere. But she’s been gone for more than 40 years now, and the connective tissue that held our family together has deteriorated badly. The connections are brittle and broken. For my daughter to have to experience this for herself is making me feel sad; I see now that this family reunion idea floated by my cousin Randy is nothing but an empty dream, a fantasy born of some ideal that does not exist between us. We are not the reunion type. We are the disconnected type, the unanswered telephone call type, the cryptic email type, the unresponsive type, the “make other arrangements that suit our needs” type.
I miss Hank and Lou. But even Hank and Lou, if they were alive today…who knows? I believe that if they were healthy, they would take Maddy in, even if they were 100 years old they would, and Uncle Hank would show her the berry bushes that the deer sneak into the yard to eat from.
My sister, my friends and I know a better way to live that is natural, open and emotionally nourishing. We gather around tables, we share food and drink and talk. And I want to cry out, Darling daughter, run! Run the other way! Don’t let this weird juju touch you. Visit for an hour, and drive far away. It looks like we moved to the other end of the coast for a reason.
Happy Birthday, John Lennon. I send out a wish for peace to the entire world, in your name.
You don’t need somebody to tell you who you are or what you are, you are who you are.
Instant karma’s gonna get you…may we all shine on.
———————
Addendum: How it all turned out: they opened their home, and everyone had a nice visit.
I am eager as the new school year approaches, and at the same time, I dread it. What I dread though is losing myself, and the things I need to feel good: adequate sleep, good eating habits, writing time, yoga (to gently hold the line against all that desk time needed for writing), walks for reflection and rumination, weight work for strength and stamina, and golf for fun and release. Intellectually, I know that I am middle-aged, but I’ve set no reliable habits to accommodate the truth of 53: If I don’t actively care for my body, I don’t just stand still — I deteriorate.
When I was younger, I had more natural resiliency — could neglect the body and recover quickly…I didn’t ache all of the time as now. Today, all my joints speak to me. My shoulders, always silent in the past, yak at me constantly. I am stiff in the neck, hips and hamstrings. The only thing I can do is resist, push against that stiffness. I feel like I’m pushing against a slowly advancing plate of ice.
My experience of pregnancy & childbirth put eighty pounds on my frame; I lost fifty. I have carried the extra 30 pounds for 22 years; few people who know me remember me before. I don’t look bad, but I don’t look good either. Beyond aesthetics, the damage of just carrying that weight on my hips and knees is more and more evident to me. Add to this the dawning understanding that my estrogen output is steadily decreasing. If I don’t lose the weight before the tap closes altogether, I may never lose it. So, I joined Weight Watchers this weekend.
Of course I know how to lose weight; of course I can hold myself accountable, and of course, I see the act of “joining up” and paying a fee to do what I already know how to do as crass consumerism. But ulimately, I surrender to this bare fact: I know all of this, have known it, yet have not adequately dealt with it in more than two decades — so let’s do something new. Really, give in the the facts. So I will pay my dues, participate with the group, count my points, drink my water, and go after it.
My narrative has been, “Yes, I am 30 pounds overweight but I carry it well. I am fit. I can still do what I want to do. I can accept it.” The narrative has to change. Without a narrative change, there is no lasting change.
In addition to constructing a new narrative — a narrative the I actually need to write and speak aloud — I have to schedule the necessary self care right into my week, and make a commitment to it.
Part of what I must construct, in the narrative, is clear articulation of what that time means to me over the course of my school year, and insist that it won’t hurt my teaching.
The sturdy counter-narrative that I must subvert: “I need to grade papers. I need to plan. I need to read.”
ALL OF THAT IS TRUE ENOUGH, so here’s the tricky part. I can’t just discard those mantras outright, like a bad habit. But I have to acknowledge what actually happens, which is, I say the mantra, cut the selfcare for the mantra, and then DO NEITHER. Instead put my face in the screen and fiddle around. (Hello, Facebook friends.)
Again, I need my screen. My computer and I must spend time together every day. But I have to manage that time, make the time productive, and limit the time.
Here I am, in the summer, and on vacation. I can structure my time any way I’d like, and I leave important things undone. So when my time is highly structured as it is during the school year, it is so much easier to leave important things left undone.
I have to be on my own side.